With Us headed to theaters this month, Jordan Peele is everywhere right about now, and we’re more than okay with that. Peele, if it wasn’t already clear, is a big time horror fan just like the rest of us, and he talks horror in a new video posted by Wall Street Journal this week.

Titled Jordan Peele’s Guide to Horror Films, the video has Peele answering several questions about horror cinema, as the site asks him to rattle of his favorite villain, favorite (and least favorite) trope, favorite final girl and more. He was also asked to assemble his own Avengers-style group of horror icons, and his answer should paint a glorious picture in your mind.

What is Peele’s first memory of watching a horror film? Watch below to find out!